Really like the fit and feel of these shirts. They felt a bit scratchy right out of the bag, but after one wash are now super soft and comfy. The fit is perfect for me - I'm 6'3 230lb, and the large is exactly right. I like that the cut is a bit on the longer size, Larges are normally a bit short on my torso.
The colors are great, the green is maybe a bit darker than the pictures, and the red isn't quite as vibrant (which is honestly a good thing in my opinion, the picture makes it look a bit fire-engine-y)
One of the shirts I ordered had a ripped stitch on the bottom hem, but support was incredibly fast getting back to me. We got it sorted out about two hours after my first email. I've messaged support about other things too and they've been incredibly helpful and responsive.
Overall, highly recommend. Great clothes, great customer support, love that they're made here in the US.